C'mon Mr. President, Wear A Mask
Notes On 2020 - The President’s defiance on masking is worth us discussing this morning. The case for masks is a powerful one - they reduce the spread of the virus, are low cost, and are simple. In poll after poll, support for wearing masks and other prudent physical distancing measures is overwhelming. In a new Huffington Post poll released last week just on masking, 63% of Americans said the President and other elected officials should wear masks. Only 7% said no. So why is the President undermining the use of this powerful and simple tool to help us return to work?
The US government only ever had a few options on what to do about COVID, and what remains extraordinary is that the President to this day has essentially chosen to do none of them. He could have initiated an early travel ban on China and Europe and, while he eventually adopted partial bans, they came far too late to stop the spread of the virus. He refused to adopt a national stay at home strategy, leaving it to the states. He’s refused to set up a national testing and tracing regime, something every other developed country in the world has in place and something that at some point America must do too if we hope to restart domestic and international travel (see this WaPo look at Germany’s tracing regime). And now he’s undermining the wearing of masks in public. From a public health standpoint it isn't all that different from recommending folks drink Clorox, or take hydroxychloroquine - it is dangerous quackery.
It turns out that this lack of really doing anything to fight COVID has left America in rough shape. We still have among the highest infection rates in the world, per capita, on par with countries like Russia, Saudi Arabia, and Brazil. We are 35th in the world in per capita testing, and while that number is improving, it is possible the virus has spread here more than any other nation in the world, which means we still lag far behind in testing against the local spread of the virus. The hit our economy and workers have taken is far worse than other developed countries. Former CDC Chief Scott Gottlieb said this weekend that COVID hospitalization rates are *increasing* in many states, including FL and GA, two of the fastest to re-open. Fundamentally, the President has failed at job one - taming the virus - at an extraordinary cost to the nation.
So despite very few states hitting the CDC’s recommended guidelines for re-opening, we are re-opening. And re-opening means more interactions, more density, and probably for a time, more infections and spread. Which is why if we are sending people back out into a world where the virus is still active, where our testing and tracing regimes still lag way behind, we should be asking people to wear masks, to protect themselves and others. It’s simple. And yet the President is refusing to do it; rather, he is mocking leaders like Joe Biden who are doing the right thing now.
We are at the point in Trump’s Presidency where we really have to start asking hard questions about whether the President is still capable of understanding what he is doing. His response to COVID has been among the greatest policy failures in our history. He isn’t learning from what has gone wrong and making course corrections. He is doing things which seem designed to harm people, spread the virus, and slow our recovery. And everything he is doing is unpopular. 49 of the 50 governors have higher approval ratings on COVID than the President, with many of the GOP Governors who have been the most aggressive at tackling COVID with the very highest ratings of all. Only 7% believe he shouldn’t be wearing a mask. His numbers have dropped in the past few weeks, and he is now well below where he was on Election Day 2018 when he lost that election by 8.6 points. The Senate also seems to be slipping away from his grasp. I was quoted in a smart NYTimes Senate analysis on Friday, saying “The Republican brand seems depressed across the board. A lot of time senators can insulate themselves from the vagaries of the national electorate, but that doesn’t seem to be happening this time. “
Also on Friday, referring to a new piece I'd written, the Washington Post wrote: “Democratic strategist Simon Rosenberg urges his party to see Trump not as someone who possesses fearsome magical political powers, but as someone who’s losing, desperate and panicking.”
If I were Mitch McConnell and House Leader McCarthy, I would do one thing now for the good of their party and the country - get the President to put on a damn mask, and ask everyone else in the country to join him in the days ahead. The Republicans just have to stop being cowards, and step in here and help our great country tame this virus in the days ahead. This war against masks, given all of Trump’s other failures, is dangerous anti-science lunacy, and the cries for it to end should be coming from all quarters now, with the loudest of all coming from the office of Mitch McConnell.
May 27th Update - New polling from the Navigating Coronavirus project show how little support there is for Trump's hostility to masking - 78% want elected official to wear masks, 74% say they are "pro-mask" and 65% disapprove of the President for not wearing a mask.